Search

Life cycle carbon analysis of packaging products containing nonwood residues: A case study on linerboard and corrugating medium, TAPPI Journal March 2024

ABSTRACT: Circularity is creating momentum toward utilizing waste feedstock in a myriad of applications. The paper industry is not an exception to this trend, and packaging products made from agricultural or agro-industrial residues are receiving more attention now than ever. Additionally, negative consumer perceptions of tree felling are accelerating the acceptance of these fibers. Nevertheless, adopting these residues raises the issue of whether they constitute a better alternative to fight climate change than wood. Answering this question is imperative to ensure that pledges to reduce carbon footprints across the industry are fulfilled. This paper aims to estimate the carbon footprint of corrugating medium and linerboard containing wheat straw and sugarcane bagasse pulp compared to analogous wood-based materials. The goal was also to understand how methodological decisions to allocate emissions to nonwood residues can affect the results. This study includes a life cycle carbon analysis spanning from cradle to grave, which comprises stages for residue production, pulping, paper-making, waste management, and corresponding transportation. For the proposed case study, the results suggest that straw- and bagasse-based medium and linerboard can present a higher carbon footprint than products made from virgin and recycled wood fibers. The main driver is the production of nonwood chemimechanical pulp. In addition, the lower capacity of nonwood residues to be recycled increases the overall impact. Finally, decisions around emissions allocation highly influence the results. This study helps mitigate part of the uncertainty around the environmental sustainability of corrugating medium and linerboard made from the selected nonwood residues.

Life cycle carbon analysis of packaging products containing purposely grown nonwood fibers: A case study on the use of switchgrass pulp for linerboard and corrugating medium, TAPPI Journal March 2024

ABSTRACT: Sustainability is driving innovation in the pulp and paper industry to produce goods with lower carbon footprints. Although most of the efforts are currently focused on increasing energy efficiency or switching to renewable fuels, the attention toward alternative feedstocks has increased in recent years. Claims of nonwood fibers requiring lower use of chemicals and energy than wood fibers, along with negative consumer perceptions of tree felling, are helping purposely grown nonwoods to gain market share. The potential nonwood fiber environmental superiority over virgin or recycled wood fibers remains controversial and is often driven more by emotion and public perception rather than facts. This paper estimates the carbon footprint of corrugating medium and linerboard containing switchgrass pulp compared to analogous wood-based materials. The study includes a life cycle carbon analysis spanning from cradle to gate, which comprises stages for fiber production, pulping, papermaking, and corresponding transportation. Carbon footprints for virgin linerboard, recycled linerboard, virgin medium, and recycled medium were estimated at around 510, 620, 460, and 670 kg carbon dioxide equivalent per metric ton (kg CO2eq/t), respectively. Replacing 30% of the virgin or recycled material with switchgrass pulp translated into carbon footprint increases of around 60%, 45%, 62%, and 38%, respectively. Thus, for the proposed case study, the results suggest that switchgrass-based medium and linerboard can present a higher carbon footprint than products made from virgin and recycled wood fibers. The main driver is the production of nonwood mechanical pulp.This study was designed to mitigate part of the uncertainty around the environmental sustainability of medium and linerboard made from the selected purposely grown nonwood fibers.

TAPPI Journal Summaries, Paper360º March/April 2024

ASPI News, Paper360º March/April 2024

Making a Difference: Meet our 2024 Award Winners, Paper360º May/June 2024

Unlocking Profit Potential: How US Pulp Mills Can Capitalize on Carbon Capture, Paper360º May/June 2024

TAPPI News, Paper360º May/June 2024

ASPI News, Paper360º May/June 2024

APP Tissues International: Onward and Upward in the Global Market, Paper360º November/December 2024

Unlikely Technology Combo KOs Large Suspended Solids, Paper360º November/December 2024